Adds the proof and clarity people need before they pay.
Deft against the best free skill we found for this job
All 3 testsout of 150
Deft110out of 150, highest
Free skill96out of 150
No skill96out of 150
A pricing pageout of 50
Deft35out of 50, highest
Free skill27out of 50
No skill26out of 50
A product pageout of 50
Deft38out of 50, highest
Free skill34out of 50
No skill34out of 50
A gift set pageout of 50
Deft37out of 50, highest
Free skill35out of 50
No skill36out of 50
Each quality, out of 10
Kept the shopDeft 9 out of 10Free skill 5 out of 10No skill 5 out of 10
The replyDeft 8 out of 10Free skill 5 out of 10No skill 6 out of 10
Trust, honestly builtDeft 7 out of 10Free skill 6 out of 10No skill 5 out of 10
WorksDeft 7 out of 10Free skill 8 out of 10No skill 8 out of 10
PersuadesDeft 6 out of 10Free skill 8 out of 10No skill 8 out of 10
See the work and how we tested
How we tested
Each test sent the same request three ways: with Deft, with the best free skill we found for this job, and with no skill at all.
The judges were AI agents, not people. They saw the three results as A, B and C with every skill name removed, and scored five qualities out of 10 each, 50 in all.
The quality scores at the top are averaged over the tests and rounded.
How we picked the free skill: no free skill covers this job alone, so we used the closest: the conversion skill from a widely used free marketing set (about 56,000 GitHub stars), with the whole set installed so its pricing and offer skills could join in.
The businesses are made up. Each result is that version’s own work, unedited, from the request shown.
The work
A pricing page
The request
This is the pricing page for my AI meeting-notes app, Notewise. Our analytics show lots of people reach pricing, look around for a bit and leave without starting a plan or a trial. Can you fix the page so more of them sign up?
Before
Deft
Free skill
No skill
The blind judge’s reasons
Deft was the only one that removed the unbacked stats, the fake sale and "SOC 2 ready", and it invented nothing. It lost points for leaving three named quotes on the page as if real. The free skill had the clearest offer but kept every fake number and invented a trial promise, and the no-skill version put an invented 14-day trial all over the page.
The judge’s scores, out of 10 each
Quality
Deft
Free skill
No skill
Trust, honestly built
7
4
3
Persuades
7
6
6
Kept the shop
8
5
5
Works
6
8
8
The reply
7
4
4
Total
35
27
26
A product page
The request
This is the jacket page of my outdoor gear shop, Larch Supply (index.html). Lots of people add the jacket to their cart, but most of them never buy. Two customers told me they weren't sure the shop was legit. Can you make people trust the shop enough to buy?
Before
Deft
Free skill
No skill
The blind judge’s reasons
Deft was the most disciplined: it fixed the fake stars, kept every review and invented nothing, but the delivery time sits far from the button and the missing shop details are hidden notes. The free skill built the most complete trust box by the button without guessing, but spread its changes over four pages and a 1,293-word reply. The no-skill version guessed the payment methods and added an unchecked "Secure checkout" claim.
The judge’s scores, out of 10 each
Quality
Deft
Free skill
No skill
Trust, honestly built
7
8
5
Persuades
6
9
8
Kept the shop
9
5
6
Works
8
7
8
The reply
8
5
7
Total
38
34
34
A gift set page
The request
I opened my hot sauce shop, Brasa, in June. This is the product page for our gift set. People visit, but hardly anyone buys. The trio is €24.90, and that's been the price since day one. I made the page with an AI store builder. Can you make it more trustworthy and get me more sales?
Before
Deft
Free skill
No skill
The blind judge’s reasons
Deft came first: it removed every fake element, invented nothing and kept the shop's look, though the vague refund answer stays on the page and the missing shipping cost and business details sit only in the owner's notes file. The no-skill version had the strongest buying area but states an invented 7-day breakage window as fact and restyled the shop unasked. The free skill was as persuasive, but it also restyled the shop, made refund promises the owner never confirmed and wrote a long reply.
